Legal Review: Anti-Drunk Driving Advocates Concerned About Virginia Removing Mandatory Minimums

Virginia’s General Assembly proposed a bill, Senate Bill 1443, that would remove mandatory minimum sentences for all crimes excluding Class 1 felonies. The bill has sparked significant concerns from anti-drunk driving organizations.

Before the bill, there were a series of mandatory minimum sentences for certain blood alcohol content levels (BAC). For a BAC of 0.08 — twice the legal limit — the offender was required to be in jail for five days. Those with a BAC of 0.2 or higher had a mandatory minimum of 10 days in jail.

There were specific stipulations for repeat offenders as well. If someone got two convictions within a five-year span, they must serve a mandatory 20 days in jail. If those two convictions took place within 10 years, that sentence is reduced to 10 days.

Senate Bill 1443 would remove these mandatory minimums, allowing the judge or jury to decide the sentence for each specific situation. Several advocacy groups have spoken about their concerns about removing mandatory minimums for drunk driving cases. They are especially concerned about extreme cases involving repeat offenders or those with astronomical blood alcohol content called “super drunk” drivers. They argue that, without mandatory minimums, drunk driving offenders may be released with minimal penalties and return to their destructive behaviors.

Crime Classifications

What classifies as a Class 1 felony varies from state to state. In Virginia, Class 1 felonies include murder and sexual abuse of a child under 15 years old. Committing these crimes can result in life imprisonment, a fine of up to $100,000.

Senate Bill 1443 would specifically keep mandatory minimum sentences in place for these felonies. However, all other crime categories would lose their mandatory minimum sentencing, such as aggravated manslaughter and child pornography. In cases involving these crimes, it would be up to the judge or jury to decide the sentencing requirements for that particular case.

Why Anti-Drunk Driving Advocates are Concerned

There is a long list of anti-drunk driving advocacy groups opposing this bill. The Washington Regional Alcohol Program, Mothers Against Drunk Driving, the American Automobile Association’s Virginia Branch, and the Foundation for Advancing Alcohol Responsibility banded together to write a letter to the General Assembly discussing their qualms with the current state of the bill.

Kurt Erikson, president of the Washington Regional Alcohol Program, explains their reservations by using the expression “throwing the baby out with the bathwater.” Essentially stating that Senate Bill 1443 is a good idea, but it should not apply to drunk driving cases.

There is some truth behind his statement. Two-thirds of drivers involved in fatal crashes had a BAC of 0.15 or higher, and on average, a Virginian dies in a car crash every 33 hours. These two statistics clearly show how drunk driving can be hazardous for Virginia’s citizenry.

However, there are some, including the Democratic State Senator John Edwards from Roanoke County, who authored the bill. He argues that judges overseeing these cases would still have the jurisdiction to impose harsh sentences. The bill would only remove mandatory minimums for a majority of drunk driving cases. His statements have done little to settle the worries of anti-drunk driving advocacy groups.

Where Are We Now

Against the concerns of several anti-drunk driving advocacy groups, Senate Bill 1443 passed with a 21-17 vote. However, many organizations are still fighting to decrease the number of people who die in DUI related car crashes.

Currently, Fairfax County has the most deaths in Virginia with an average of 19 DUI related fatalities each year between 2006 and 2010. Fairfax Criminal Lawyers are working with the Fairfax County Police Department in a campaign called Checkpoint Strikeforce in an attempt to decrease these numbers.

Even while making these attempts to decrease the number of DUI cases, advocacy groups are still concerned about what this could mean for future drunk driving cases. It has yet to be seen how removing mandatory minimums may affect the number and severity of drunk drivers on Virginia’s roadways.

Recent Stories

The Georgia-based pizza restaurant Mellow Mushroom will open a location in Vienna (courtesy Shannon Curl/Mellow Mushroom) Mellow Mushroom is officially coming to the Town of Vienna. The Atlanta, Georgia-based pizza…

Bicycles parked outside the Greensboro Metro station entrance in Tysons (staff photo by Angela Woolsey) Fairfax County hopes to increase the availability of bicycle parking spaces by establishing a tiered…

This Saturday, December 3 Wolf Trap’s Holiday Sing-A-Long returns to the Filene Center after two years of virtual performances! Guests are invited to take part in this free tradition that…

The Boro in Tysons will kick off its winter holiday festivities this Saturday (courtesy The Boro) Officially, winter won’t come for another three weeks, but as far as the Tysons…

Chris Green is one of the DMV’s finest fitness instructors. A Lululemon and South Block ambassador, he is a coach and mentor to so many. He embodies grace, positivity and motivation in ways that no one else can. If we could all learn a thing or two from him, the world would be a much better place. He does so much for others, and does so with a smile on his face 99% of the time.

He recently ruptured his Achilles and has an incredibly long and tough journey ahead. As if COVID hadn’t impacted fitness professionals enough, throw this in the mix and it’s a double, even triple whammy. CG is no longer able to work and do what he loves for the time being because of this and we’d love your support.

Read More

Submit your own Community Post here for just $99.

The Rhea Baker State Farm Agency is proud to support Shelter House in providing safe places to be during quarantine. Shelter House’s mission is to prevent and end homelessness and domestic violence. Right now they are providing over 200 hotel rooms to those in need in our community. In the past year, across all programs, Shelter House served nearly 500 households comprised of over 1,500 individuals, 60% of which were children.

Of the households that exited shelter, over 70% moved to permanent housing. The Baker Agency has served Vienna and Tysons residents and business owners since 2007 and proudly offers insurance solutions for you home, condo, auto insurance, life insurance and more. We offer complimentary reviews and coach teen drivers to safer, better drivers, and to help keep your auto insurance rates down! We are always happy to talk or text at 703-847-6880.

Submit your own Community Post here for just $99.


Subscribe to our mailing list